Hey Jason,
You know I totally respect you and your art, and what you contribute to this community. Actually I don't see it that 501st should be able to recast non-501st w/o punishment, but there was recently added language to the charter that makes this the case, e.g. a DL cannot ban a 501st member for recasting w/o first complaining to that persons' GCO and going through the COG, plus some other hand tying that's been added. So while if Terrell had recasted Tony I'd have wanted to do the same thing, I'd have to go through some paperwork to make that attempt with no guarantee that I'd be successful.
With regards to non-501st it's definitely a judgment call for the DL just like it is for a GCO on their garrison boards. Some garrisons are very open about recasting and the CO's actively support and encourage it. Others are very adamant against it and hunt it down. Detachments are no different, and like much of the charter there is room for interpretation.
My concern is in protecting the prop makers without whom very few of us would be able to participate in this hobby. LFL allows us - and by us I mean 501st members - a limited ability to produce armor for our own use. This protection does not apply to non-501st people. This along with the charter specifically stating that we don't condone recasting means that I can protect the rights of 501st prop maker. I like some other DL's also choose to extend this blanket to other prop makers like TM, but this is not required by me at all.
I don't consider it my job to hunt down and prosecute recasters, and those of you who know who is on this board and what they do can clearly see that I could be very aggressive in weeding members should I choose to.
What makes Dave stand out is that he, as a 501st member, knew the rules, was blatant about violating the rules, and was completely unapologetic as well. He specifically targeted a 501st member for his work. This wasn't someone trying to fly under the radar or make a few copies for his garrison buddies. This wasn't a case of recasting CAP who could care less.
The more I examine the situation the more convinced I am I did the right thing, and for the right reasons.
Paul