I dare you to take that argument over to the clonetrooper detachment.. HAHA!
Gotta say though guys, I disagree. I love the Clone Wars and the animated clones. Phase 2 definitely was an improvement from phase 1. So who knows, maybe the Rebels stormtroopers will evolve the same way and go through a re-design a few seasons in. We'll just have to watch the show, won't we.. Also, while Dave Filoni and George Lucas obviously appreciate and endorse the Star Wars costuming community, we are merely a 'drop in the bucket' when it comes to creating new Star Wars material for millions of fans, making Lucasfilm millions and billions of dollars. I highly doubt there has been any mention in any 'Rebels' design meeting as to what the costuming community is going to think about a particular design. As cool as it would be if the 501st legion were creative consultants for Lucasfilm on all things trooper related, sadly we are not. I think we just have to accept that not everything released in the Star Wars universe (especially animation) is going to be, or needs to be, screen accurate. We're getting more Star Wars.. TONS of it! Let's just take a deep breath, not quit the 501st, and appreciate what we're getting.