Jump to content

Remnant Stormtrooper CRL Discussion Thread


BigJasoni

Recommended Posts

38 minutes ago, justjoseph63 said:

Just throwing this out there because it's bugging me, but does anyone else find this pic a bit odd?  To me at least it looks like an extra piece on the top of the calf (left arrow) but it could be gaffa tape.  Also, the back line of the calf is clearly visible and comes straight up, but it appears that the ridge extends out over it leaving a space (right arrow).  I'm thinking it just got crunched and that the calf split at the ridge.  Or maybe I'm just crazy, lol.

 

WlB8SIh.jpg    2EIB3Ja.jpg

It's tape, you can see the rectangle shape in the image below, poor trooper has quite a bit of tape on him, I guess being used as a stunt version he would. There is tape on his shoulder straps, lower calf bottom, around the belt (worse one Iv'e seen) and on his chest.

mandalorian2x06_1162.thumb.jpg.baf119c25bd66868009ef23dcbb4c8f6.jpg

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Adding only remnant references

 

SE-14R

4k-mandalorians01e01-starwarsscreencaps.

4k-mandalorians01e03-starwarsscreencaps.

 

E-22 No light but has mount

4k-mandalorians01e08-starwarsscreencaps.

 

E-11 has light and mount

4k-mandalorians01e01-starwarsscreencaps.

4k-mandalorians01e03-starwarsscreencaps.

Working lights

4k-mandalorians01e03-starwarsscreencaps.

4k-mandalorians01e03-starwarsscreencaps.

 

Boots heels and side elastic

boots.png.58735c5f882d91dbe9e5006367d6acab.png

boots2.thumb.png.fa88631174d89e79a2afc84a615983a2.png

 

Belt trimmed 

belt.thumb.png.68f960b262614a0234dd1171ad01daa3.png

 

Belt full

belt2.thumb.png.59b9920df0b8cc9ac1bcd67fb6dc5e46.png

1531472121_belt3.thumb.png.4354f0a5e6de9e9fe4b1f2e9cdd18bb6.png

 

 Boot loops

boots5.thumb.png.ca8a6233d431979851a68db4778aa5ba.png

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Some suggestions, wording may not be correct as I'm not a wordsmith, references added were possible due to lack of some remnant references.

 

Why I added the brownish hue to the weathering is the weathering is very dark in a lot of areas but can be clearly seen that it has a wash of brown.

 

Added a few changes to the helmet as we know this is a Anovos ANH helmet so details will be specific to that helmet - perhaps Denuo Novo will produce one if they purchased the molds/plans, entirely up to the DO and LMO's if they allow other ANH era helmets and not just Anovos

 

helmet.thumb.png.ceb3fd14d36048456132e4990cad21f4.png

 

Note there I've found two versions of the Anovos OT ANH helmet, I believe this one was the later 2017 onwards

DtVeGXf.jpg21559025_10159361238725029_6616842612411894087_n.jpg.0bfa8fd756c130997b3737d929a4c0d9.jpg

 

Prior to 2017 differences, fuller teeth paint, inside hovis all white

11194390_899817496749930_2310008650701497520_o.thumb.jpg.aadb4f0a5f1ead6d75181ca76acf6311.jpg

 

 

Helmet

  • Moderate to heavily weathered with a brownish hue
  • Traps (trapezoids on dome of helmet) and tears (area beneath the corners of eye lenses) are gray.
  • Rear traps and tears have vertical black lines.
  • Lenses are flat material, green in color, sufficiently dark enough to obscure the costumer's eyes.
  • The “ear” bars have three or four bumps and are gray or painted gray, with a black outline. Painting the bumps with rank stripes (highlighted) in black is optional.
  • Frown is painted gray and does not leave the teeth area. A total of 8 cut outs in the teeth area of the frown are present.
  • Tube stripes are medium blue, numbering between 9 and 16 15 per side with the curve bends extending backwards. 
  • Vocoder (vertically ribbed chin detail) is painted black.
  • Aerators/Hovi-MIX tips (cylinders on either side of the vocoder) are black or painted black.
  • Tears, traps, and tube stripes may be hand painted, decals, or decals that replicate hand painted.
  • Mesh may be used behind the frown to obscure the face of the wearer.
  • Note: The helmet is accurate in detail and proportion to official references.
    • Many commercially available helmets or those considered disproportionate in size or shape are ineligible.

 

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

  • Ears shall have three screws per side, one above and one below the ear bar and one at the base of the helmet.
  • Ear bars have four bumps only.
    • Not three.
  • Traps/tears and tube stripes shall have the correct ANH TK details.
  • Ideally, the tube stripes are positioned approximately a pencil width from the side of the cheek.
  • Fall of tube stripe tops ideally lean toward the front.
  • Correct Aerators/Hovi-MIX tips are present. Screens used shall be of a wide type mesh, with the rim of the mic and the inside nipple white or painted white.

 

OPTIONAL Level three certification (if applicable):

  • Ear bars shall have only one bump painted in black (rank stripes).
  • Ideally, placement of ears (and screws) should closely follow the rear angle of the trap above them
  • Neck trim shall be of an s-type profile rather than a u-type profile.
  • Tears/traps shall be hand painted or use decals that emulate hand painted (with correct ANH TK details).
  • Ear screws shall be slotted, flat topped, countersunk and painted white.
  • The vocoder must be integrated into the helmet, and not a separate piece.

 

 

Neck Seal

  • Moderate to heavily weathered with a brownish hue
  • Black with horizontal ribs, fitted to the wearer, and extending from the base of the neck to conceal the entire neck

 

 

 

 

No thigh ribs

rem.thumb.jpg.8bccfcd7f9cddc4246be1ed7b682aaa2.jpg

Under Suit

  • Moderate to heavily weathered with a brownish hue
  • Black non-textured material, either one-piece or two-piece construction with no visible zippers or logos/designs.

 

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

  • Top, where visible shall be fully ribbed with all horizontal ribbing on the arms, chest, and back. The centre of chest and back may be mesh as long as it is covered by armor.
  • Pants shall be black non-textured material and have horizontal ribbing at the knees only. Knee gaskets are allowed as long as they correctly match top ribbing material, spacing and color.
  • The hip section shall not have ribs.

 

OPTIONAL Level three certification (if applicable):

  • All ribbing on knees, arms, chest, and back must be stitched between each rib in detail and proportion to official references.
  • The armpit area shall have the correct hexagonal mesh detail

 

 

 

Shoulder Straps

  • Moderate to heavily weathered with a brownish hue
  • These shall be inserted behind the chest tabs and into slots of the backplate.
  • They may be affixed with Velcro or adhesive.

 

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

 

OPTIONAL Level three certification (if applicable):

  • These shall be inserted behind the chest tabs and into slots of the backplate.
  • Shall be made of latex or latex like material

 

 

Shoulder Armor

  • Moderate to heavily weathered with a brownish hue
  • One on each shoulder.
  • The shoulders are considered effectively symmetrical; they may be worn interchangeably on the left and right shoulders and may have a black elastic strap that wraps around the inside of the bicep.

 

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

 

OPTIONAL Level three certification (if applicable):

  • There is no swoop on the shoulder bell raised area.
  • There is no elastic strap that wraps around the inside of the bicep.

 

Upper Arm Armor

  • Moderate to heavily weathered with a brownish hue
  • Both biceps are symmetrical and interchangeable.
  • The front strip is bevelled and approximately 1/8" thick that does not extend beyond the bicep, and has a smaller cover strip layered thereon.

 

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

 

OPTIONAL Level three certification (if applicable):

  • Cover strips will cover both the front and back joints.
  • Biceps are loosely held closed in the back with elastic, shock cord (bungee cord) or white Velcro and are designed to remain flexible.

 

Forearm Armor

  • Moderate to heavily weathered with a brownish hue
  • The front strip is bevelled and approximately 1/8" thick that does not extend beyond the bicep, and has a smaller cover strip layered thereon.

 

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

 

OPTIONAL Level three certification (if applicable):

  • Forearms are loosely held closed in the back with elastic, shock cord (bungee cord) or white Velcro and are designed to remain flexible.
  • Cover strips will cover both the top and bottom joints.

 

Hand Plates

  • Moderate to heavily weathered with a brownish hue
  • Roughly pentagonal in shape, the hand plates are mounted securely over the back of the glove. As an alternative to plastic, these may be made out of latex or latex-like material.

 

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

  • Hand guards shall be made of plastic.

 

OPTIONAL Level three certification (if applicable):

  • Hand guards should follow the correct RO shape, ANH hand guards are not acceptable.
  • A small indent in the front of the hand plate shall be present.

 

Gloves

  • Moderate to heavily weathered with a brownish hue
  • Black in color, made of either rubber, Nomex, leather, or leather-like material, with no visible straps or logos/designs. The fingers are enclosed, non-textured.

 

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

  • Gloves shall not be made of rubber.

 

OPTIONAL Level three certification (if applicable):

  • The base material of the gloves will be a black synthetic material similar to Lycra, Spandex, Elastane, or Nylon.
  • Palms of gloves shall be shiny black fabric or leather or leather-like material.
  • On the index finger shall be a stitched piece of fabric made from the same material as the hand's underside that while stitched to the finger has one cutout towards the end of the finger that reveals the netted material underneath.
  • Gloves shall have the correct leather pattern along the fingers/palm.

 

Chest Armor

  • Moderate to heavily weathered with a brownish hue
  • Chest plate overlaps the abdominal plate

 

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

  • There are raised trapezoids at the top of the shoulder section beneath which the straps insert.
  • The chest and back sides shall be connected by black extensions pieces.

 

OPTIONAL Level three certification (if applicable):

  • Top pectoral out lines swoop correctly outward.
  • Bottom of ribcage flares correctly outward.

 

Back Armor

  • Moderate to heavily weathered with a brownish hue
  • Back plate contains an "O II" design.
  • There are raised trapezoids at the top of the backplate section beneath which the shoulder straps insert. The backplate continues past these trapezoids towards the top of the shoulder

 

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

  • There are raised trapezoids at the top of the backplate section beneath which the shoulder straps insert. The backplate continues past these trapezoids towards the top of the shoulder
  • Top of box wall has a trapezoidal indentation.
  • There is a roughly 8mm circular indent near the right top corner of the backplate.

 

OPTIONAL Level three certification (if applicable):

  • Bottom of backplate is curved and extends past abdominal back cover plate.
  • The O cog shall have 16 spines.
  • The 11 bars have 5 horizontal evenly spaced raised bars on the bottom of the face.
  • There is a rectangular tab protruding from the bottom of each of the two raised trapezoids at the top of the backplate.

 

Abdomen Armor

  • Moderate to heavily weathered with a brownish hue
  • The abdominal armor consists of a one-piece corset design with a vertical opening centred on the back.
  • The back opening is covered by a rectangular cover plate that is worn under the back armor.
  • There are 3 vertical ribs centered on the front of the abdomen and two (one left and one right) ribs further spaced to each side of the center.
  • There are two (one left and one right) angled (approximately 70 degrees) ribs on each side of the abdominal armor.
  • There are two (one left and one right) angled (approximately 70 degrees) recessed ribs on each side of the abdominal armor behind the raised angled ribs that are black
  • Any side shims added are to be added to the white areas of the armor.
  • The center front detail consists of a raised rectangular panel. On the right half of the panel, there is a vertical column of 4 buttons approximately 7/16” (11mm) in diameter. The bottom button is blue while the other three are grey. On the left half of the panel, there is a vertical column of raised evenly spaced horizontal gear teeth with a recessed trapezoid at the top of the column. The rectangular inside bottom of the trapezoid is black.
  • The left front detail consists of a raised rectangular panel with an angled top. There is a vertical column of 4 buttons approximately 7/16” (11mm) in diameter. The bottom button is blue while the other three are grey.
  • The right front detail consists of a primary raised rectangular panel with an additional secondary raised rectangular panel covering the top 1/3 of the primary panel. There is a column of three thin horizontal evenly spaced raised lines across the top ½ of the secondary panel.
  • The abdominal armor is accurate in detail and proportion to official references.

 

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

  • The cod armor is separate from the abdominal armour.
  • The right front detail panel is centered between the two outer vertical right ribs.
  • The left front detail panel is centered between the two outer vertical left ribs.

 

OPTIONAL Level three certification (if applicable):

  • The abdomen armor has two horizontal recessed rectangles centred above the center front detail panel and on each side of the center rib.
  • All 8 Button details are recessed and bordered with a thin edge, only the recessed portion is painted.
  • The center front panel column of raised gear teeth has only 9 teeth.
  • There is a recessed edge (approximately 1/8” 3mm wide) along all four sides around the face of the center front panel
  • The right front detail panel is centered between the two outer vertical right ribs.
  • The left front detail panel is centered between the two outer vertical left ribs.
  • There is a recessed edge (approximately 1/8” 3mm wide) along the sides and top around the face of the left front detail pane
  • The abdominal armor back cover plate has two protruding tabs along the bottom that rest inside the back hard belt.

 

 

 

cod.png.d5c89832dca876491d9cb026b9097c66.png

Cod Armor

  • Moderate to heavily weathered with a brownish hue
  • The cod armor consists of a body shape formed triangular plate with a raised center rib and raised lower portion and is accurate in detail and proportion to official references.

 

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

  • The cod shall be a separate piece from the abdominal plate.

 

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

  • There is no strap between the cod and butt plate

 

 

 

 

Kidney Armor

  • Moderate to heavily weathered with a brownish hue
  • The kidney armor is separated in the back and covered by a rectangular plate.
  • The rectangular plate is separate from the posterior armor.

 

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

 

OPTIONAL Level three certification (if applicable):

 

 

 

108434857_strapscod.png.870bbe66d5e01144129eaff76f24dd0b.png

Posterior Armor

  • Moderate to heavily weathered with a brownish hue
  • The posterior armor shall be a separate piece from the abdominal armor

 

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

 

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

  • There is no strap between the cod and butt plate

 

 

 

 

belt.thumb.png.b54a41dad0d8d9574d85dba52e3f2dd8.png

overlap.png.07bcf57849eca83dda7392459de717f3.png

198636016_frontbelt.png.d5521d72dd8dafb1028080bcdcc752b2.png

 

Belt

  • Moderate to heavily weathered with a brownish hue
  • The Ammunition belt consists of a hard belt made of the same or similar material as the armor in two separate parts front and back, they can be either butted together or overlapped (with overlap).
  • The back belt overlaps the front belt on the sides
  • There are 6 ammunition boxes mounted to the belt.
  • There are 2 (one left and one right) drop boxes suspended by black webbing approximately 2" (50mm) wide. Drop boxes must be accurate in detail and proportion to official references.
  • The ammunition belt is accurate in detail and proportion to official references.
  • Bottom of belt may be completely straight or trimmed angular from the sides of the cod up to the drop boxes.

 

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

  • The only detail visible on the front belt is the mounted ammunition boxes unlike the squares present on ANH belts.
  • The top edge of the front belt has protruding teeth that nest inside gaps between the ribs and detail panels of the abdominal armor.
  • The two center ammunition boxes are thinner than the other mounted ammunition boxes.
  • The second and fifth mounted ammunition boxes are slightly wider than the two center ammunition boxes.
  • The two outermost ammunition boxes are almost square.
  • The two drop boxes are rectangular and as wide as the mounted square boxes.

 

OPTIONAL Level three certification (if applicable):

  • The ammo boxes across the front are all made separately from the main belt and are secured to it
  • The two drop boxes hang no more than 1” 25mm below the front belt and the black strap is visible.
  • The second and fifth mounted ammunition boxes have trapezoid detail on the top of each ammunition box.
  • The front belt protrudes past all mounted ammunition boxes above and below by approximately 1/8”-1/4” 3-6mm.
  • All ammunition boxes have slightly bevelled edges on the face of each box.

 

Thermal Detonator

  • Moderate to heavily weathered with a brownish hue
  • The thermal detonator consists of a grey tube approximately 3” 76mm in diameter and 8” 203mm long approximately.
  • There are two white endcaps and a white control panel.
  • The white control panel has a horizontal row of white rectangles along the bottom of the control panel and a grey “D” shaped recessed on the left side of the horizontal row.
  • There is an oval greeble that protrudes from the control near the top right side.
  • The thermal detonator is mounted to the rear hard belt and there are no visible screws or clips and is accurate in detail and proportion to official references.

 

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

  • The thermal detonator mount should be fully enclosed with solid walls on all four sides.
  • The center of both end caps is gray.

 

OPTIONAL Level three certification (if applicable):

  • The control panel bottom detail is a raised panel with 7 raised rectangles, all are evenly spaced except the right most rectangle.
  • There is a panel line approximately ¼” 6mm from the edge around the control panel.
  • There is a panel line approximately 1/8” 3mm from the edge of each endcap.
  • The inside edge of both endcaps is bevelled.
  • The oval greeble consists of an oval tube protrusion with the top edge slightly extending past the tube wall thickness and is visually similar to the Deathtrooper chin greeble.

 

 

straps.thumb.png.57e3ddc9f2b352e527adb546e1700d51.png

Thigh Armor

  • Moderate to heavily weathered with a brownish hue
  • The thigh armor is mirrored for each leg and not interchangeable.
  • The cover strips are bevelled and approximately 1/8" thick that does not extend beyond the thigh and has a smaller cover strip layered thereon.
  • The top edge of the thigh armor is unadorned, and the bottom edge has a raised detail that fallows the bottom edge contour.
  • The small ammo belt consists of 5 evenly spaced rectangle ammunition boxes and is installed on the bottom of the right thigh, there are no visible screws or rivets.

 

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

  • Thighs are loosely held closed in the back with elastic, shock cord (bungee cord) or white Velcro and are designed to remain flexible.
  • Cover strips will cover both the front and rear joints.

 

OPTIONAL Level three certification (if applicable):

  • The bottom outside edges of the small ammunition belt are angled at approximately 45 degrees.
  • Thigh armor is suspended by a black strap 2 black straps approximately 1” 25mm in width with a plastic side release buckle that is covered by black webbing or elastic material that runs down the side seam of the leg.

 

Lower Leg Armor

  • Moderate to heavily weathered with a brownish hue
  • The greaves are mirrored for each leg and are not interchangeable.
  • The top edge of the greaves has a raised detail that fallows the top edge contour.
  • The bottom edge of the greaves flairs out to cover the top of the ankle and boots.
  • The cover strips are bevelled and approximately 1/8" thick that does not extend beyond the greave and has a smaller cover strip layered thereon.
  • Greaves are loosely held closed in the back with elastic, shock cord (bungee cord) or white Velcro and are designed to remain flexible.
  • Cover strips will cover both the front and rear joints.
  • The trapezoid knee plate (sniper knee plate) is affixed to the top of the left greave and there are no visible screws or rivets.
  • Sniper knee plate must be aligned with the vertical cover strip and the top raised edge detail on the greave and is accurate in detail and proportion to official reference.

 

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

  • The sniper knee plate has raised detail that fallows the top edge contour.
  • The sniper knee plate has 3 trapezoidal lugs on each side and 2 on the center bottom edge (totalling 8) of the knee plate.

 

OPTIONAL Level three certification (if applicable):

 

 

 

boots5.thumb.png.904b41ffcb2d93ca28f638f1b5b6246b.png

boots2.png

Boots

  • Moderate to heavily weathered with a brownish hue
  • Boots are above ankle height and the same style as the First Order TK. Jodhpur / Chelsea type boots in the style of OT TK are not acceptable. or an equivalent style is acceptable
  • Boots are all white, ankle height and made of leather or leather-like material
  • Flat black soles without a heel.
  • Patent leather or high gloss is not permitted.
  • Small U-shaped elastic sections on both sides of the ankle.
  • Flat sole with a short heel.
  • No buckles or laces.
  • Elvis or Mariachi boots are not allowed.

 

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

  • There is no seam present on the front of the boot.
  • The wearer's inner side of the boots have zippers and no side elastic.
  • Boots have a black sole 

 

OPTIONAL Level three certification (if applicable):

  • Boots have rear tabs/loops

 

242703560_10159540468549250_6317896778074949469_n.jpg

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

--Edit-- I missed Glen's previous post with all the additions, including brownish hue weathering. I will review it and add changes to the original post later.

 

 

Everyone,

These have all been excellent observations. I think one major thing we can take away from all of this is that the Remnants and New Generation TK costumes have taken a significant amount of abuse and the props department has been incredibly busy executing "field expedient repairs" on all the gear. Honestly, it makes sense when you compare and contrast the stunt work and general movement the TKs of today are executing when compared to the OT films. Overall, I feel that the costumes are stressed a lot more than they were in the late 70s and early 1980s, so we can expect to see frequent usage of tape and broken pieces. They're also fairly easy to find if that's what we're looking for.


However, in the spirit of defining the uniform aspects of these costumes, I want to address the things that appear consistent between what we're seeing as well as these new things that continue to pop up. With that said, I'm going to update my original post with a few of the items we've agreed on thus far. For the Remnant, the OT helmet is a must. For the New Generation TK armor, including Remnant, I think we agree that the lower belt "tab" was an intended part of this costume that was either broken off, or removed on a case by case basis. Also, I'm going to add the red pauldron as an accessory for the New Generation TK to compliment the orange, black and white ones available for the ROTK. However, for those interested in the Mortar Trooper (yellow), I think that should either be an extra tab under the CRL, or a separate CRL altogether. Additionally, for blasters, we can confirm the addition of at least the SE-14R and E-22, but are waiting for additional reference photos to add for the New Generation costume. I think I spotted an E-10 in The Mandalorian season 1, plus there's this TK holding what appears to be a T-21.

fH8F2Yu.jpg 

Regardless, please keep the references coming in.

 

On 8/28/2022 at 5:27 PM, gmrhodes13 said:

So I would have thought the front belt overlaps the back belt BUT then I found this front image, this belt butts up next to the other with no overlap. Even the two other pictures showing a small overlap still wouldn't cover all of that velcro.

 

And again an overlap of belt from front to back, this time with no velcro on the bottom of the rear belt section, perhaps thy did away with it. Once again this just means we will have to decide on a standardised look

 

Celebration display trooper's belt overlaps front over back, but again no velcro 

 

Appears the common look is front overlap back belt. In this image trooper on the left has glue residue where the belt has moved.


The Belt:
I completely agree that the front overlaps the back which stands in contrast to what we have in the Rogue One TK CRL. Here's one of the references from Rogue One showing the back overlapping the front:


olxiA7N.jpg

But the majority of the references I can find show the front overlapping the back:

Ux6NjLV.jpg

ROTK on Scariff

 

V91RfHJ.jpg

ROTK at CE 2016.

 

Eo5fJ1x.jpg

TK in Solo where it's either front over the back, or butting up end to end. Seems like there's more reference photos from Rogue One and Solo where the front overlaps the back, but that is also consistent with the newer productions.

 

LcWq6tZ.jpg

 

Edmc5zz.jpg

Celebration 2022. So, team these up with the pictures Glen posted and I think it's clear that the intent was for the front to overlap the back. However, for the TKs who appear to have waist sizes larger than 30"/ 76 cm, the ends of the front and rear belts appear to butt up against each other. My suspicion regarding the tape is that it was simply added to hold things together, especially for the stunt actors who were a little more physical than the others. 
 

On 8/28/2022 at 5:27 PM, gmrhodes13 said:

On the right we see a trooper who must be a little wider than the standard sized troopers, his backplate doesn't cover the ab/back so as this is wider we also see the two buckles from the harness

back.thumb.png.2aa6db98485adfc4d980c8c58802c095.png

I think you're right. This TK just appears to have grabbed whatever was available at the time. I've seen a few different back plates that make me think that the actors had small, medium and large options, but whoever helped this trooper get dressed must have picked last. If you look at the TK on the far left, the kidney plate appears to extend much further to the side.

 

On 8/29/2022 at 4:40 AM, justjoseph63 said:

Just throwing this out there because it's bugging me, but does anyone else find this pic a bit odd?  To me at least it looks like an extra piece on the top of the calf (left arrow) but it could be gaffa tape.  Also, the back line of the calf is clearly visible and comes straight up, but it appears that the ridge extends out over it leaving a space (right arrow).  I'm thinking it just got crunched and that the calf split at the ridge.  Or maybe I'm just crazy, lol.

 

WlB8SIh.jpg    2EIB3Ja.jpg

This is interesting, but I think it's a malfunction of some sort. I'm not sure how the costumes are pieced together for the actors on set, but from just looking at it, it makes me think that the trim at the top of the shin armor just wasn't secured to the rear. This may be another one of those broken pieces. To me, it looks like the shin armor cracked when they Velcroed the rear "clam shell" together. Here I am attempting to emulate the look with my Mr Paul shin armor:
 

YmuNIIm.jpg

Not quite the same, but I think this illustrates what I'm trying to say. Also, I haven't seen any other references that look like this, so again I assume something's just going awry with the costume.

Edited by BigJasoni
Link to comment
Share on other sites

One thing I forgot to note earlier, I added the J hook and 1" webbing that passes through the bicep to the original post. These elements of the armor keep reappearing in scene after scene. I know we typically don't cover strapping in the CRLs, but similar to the strap holding up the thighs or the webbing holding the drop box, this continues to be a prominent element of the costume:
w4lJYKv.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

"...I think it's a malfunction of some sort. I'm not sure how the costumes are pieced together for the actors on set, but from just looking at it, it makes me think that the trim at the top of the shin armor just wasn't secured to the rear". 

 

I think you may be onto something, Jason, and it would explain my earlier post.  Glen is absolutely right... that is definitely a piece of gaffa tape on the side, but the shadow under the raised ridge is what was throwing me, and your image made me feel a little less crazy, lol.

Note in both screen caps that the tape goes UNDER the ridge.  I'm thinking this was a one-off.. where the ridge broke off of the calf, but why would they put the tape under it?   Hmmmm.  The plot thickens.

 

SirHSbl.jpg   T79jdpy.jpg    9qCK4Ya.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, BigJasoni said:

One thing I forgot to note earlier, I added the J hook and 1" webbing that passes through the bicep to the original post. These elements of the armor keep reappearing in scene after scene. I know we typically don't cover strapping in the CRLs, but similar to the strap holding up the thighs or the webbing holding the drop box, this continues to be a prominent element of the costume:
w4lJYKv.jpg

 

Due to the complexity of that attachment, I don't think this was a one time thing... it takes time and effort to rig up something like that.  As you mentioned, we don't normally scrutinize strapping, but if we can find enough screen caps showing this set-up it should probably be a requirement for Centurion.. maybe even EI.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, BigJasoni said:

One thing I forgot to note earlier, I added the J hook and 1" webbing that passes through the bicep to the original post. These elements of the armor keep reappearing in scene after scene. I know we typically don't cover strapping in the CRLs, but similar to the strap holding up the thighs or the webbing holding the drop box, this continues to be a prominent element of the costume:
w4lJYKv.jpg

For me this would really be for higher level approval as we don't normally see these stationary I can't see the need for them for your base builder.

 

Also for the Remnant I'm only looking at Remnant troopers and their references, I know when some aren't available we have to base on past costumes as per Rogue One. Once we have the Remnant CRL locked in I'll spend some time on next gen differences, doing both at once may get confusing. 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, justjoseph63 said:

Due to the complexity of that attachment, I don't think this was a one time thing... it takes time and effort to rig up something like that.  As you mentioned, we don't normally scrutinize strapping, but if we can find enough screen caps showing this set-up it should probably be a requirement for Centurion.. maybe even EI.

 

29 minutes ago, gmrhodes13 said:

For me this would really be for higher level approval as we don't normally see these stationary I can't see the need for them for your base builder.

 I definitely agree with both of you. I think I listed this as a Level 3 requirement in the draft. I'll pull up my other reference images, but this has appeared a couple times on TKs recently and a few times on the Shoretrooper and ICAT driver.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

30 minutes ago, BigJasoni said:

 

 I definitely agree with both of you. I think I listed this as a Level 3 requirement in the draft. I'll pull up my other reference images, but this has appeared a couple times on TKs recently and a few times on the Shoretrooper and ICAT driver.

Indeed you did add it at L3, I was just agreeing, in a round about only had one coffee way :laugh1:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We know the RO had the bicep hooks straps but I'm yet to see them on a Remnant trooper, this is where we would have to presume they would be the same, but in saying that they should look a particular way.

 

Celebration images, note the position of the biceps to shoulder bells, cover strip @ in alignment to end of the shoulder bells and take special note of the middle strap on the bicep which should connect directly to the shoulder bell so no rotation.

large.costumes_of_rogue_one____stormtroo

 

large.costumes_of_rogue_one____stormtroo

 

But if we look at biceps on the Remnant troopers some are rotated compared to the shoulder bells, some are lifted off the biceps, some have turned to nearly facing forward, I doubt this could happen if they where strapped in the RO manner but again it's just presuming how they should be or how they should work.

arms3.thumb.png.bfa8ff3dfe87344eb05688968e941215.png

 

arms2.thumb.png.548b0cf2101766a590fe49027e76694e.png

 

arms1.thumb.png.7c7dd8e051291000e787ba6bf6e1a80c.png

 

4k-mandalorians01e01-starwarsscreencaps.

 

But we do know they were on other troopers in Mandalorian

arm2.thumb.jpg.d41e9e5732b92622a64bf759a7c27b39.jpg

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Optional Accessories

Items below are optional costume accessories. These items are not required for approval, but if present appear as described below. If adding in an accessory after initial approval, the item still needs to be submitted to local GML for approval before use.

 

E-11 Blaster

  • Weathering is optional 8/24/2022
  • Manufactured by BlasTech Industries, the E-11 is standard-issue for many Imperial troops. Light, compact yet powerful, the E-11 blaster is always in high demand throughout the galaxy.

               "Note, the E-11 holster as seen in the Original Trilogy movies is not an authorized accessory for rogue One armor".

  • No holster allowed 
  • Based on a real or replica Sterling Airsoft Gun, Sterling Sub-Machine Gun, scratch-built, or a modified commercial toy Stormtrooper blaster.
  • A small flashlight shall be mounted on the right side of the blaster centred over the T-Tracks.

 

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

  • Blaster shall be based on a real or replica S&T Sterling L2A1 AEG Airsoft Gun. (Folding Stock does not need to function)
  • D-Ring shall be present on the rear end cap.
  • Scope shall be a real or replica M.H.R. (Minneapolis Honeywell Regulator Co.) M38 Telescope. 1943 model is preferred.
  • Counter shall be a real or replica Hengstler 400 Series counter. Eagle logo is preferred.
  • Power Cylinders shall be mounted on top of the magazine well. R1 style power cylinders are preferred over ANH style.
  • 6 rows of T-Tracks cover the Sterling receiver holes except for the lower left row with the bayonet lug.
  • Flashlight shall be a real or replica Element M300A Mini Scout Light.
  • 3D printed blasters can not contain visible print lines and must be sanded smooth for a more realistic appearance.

 

OPTIONAL Level three certification (if applicable):

  • Scope shall be a real or replica 1943 M.H.R. Co. M38 Telescope, 1942 model is not allowed.
  • Counter shall be a real or replica Hengstler 400 Series counter with Small eagle logo. Large eagle logo is not allowed.
  • Power Cylinders shall be R1 style, ANH style is not allowed.
  • Blaster must be weathered
  • If flashlight is fitted must be working (this requirement consistent with other CRL's) 

mandalorian1x03_1445.thumb.jpg.1b8f84469c86315b7e867ddac252d833.jpg

 

SE-14r Light Repeating Blaster

  • Weathering is optional 8/24/2022
  • SE-14r Light Repeating Blaster.
  • The barrel detailing is evident with the cocking lever and slider in place.
  • The ejection port is also evident.
  • The scope mount looks similar to the magazine but smaller in size.

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

  • Must have the correct 4 x 20 scope

OPTIONAL Level three certification (if applicable)

  • Blaster must be weathered

 

 

 

4k-mandalorians01e08-starwarsscreencaps.

E-22 Blaster

  • Weathering is optional 8/24/2022
  • Based on a real or replica Sterling sub-machine gun, scratch-built, cast, 3D print or a modified commercial toy Stormtrooper blaster. It has a extended stock attached at the rear and a extended front housing with second lower barrel.
  • Tactical flashlight (Surefire scout M300 or replica) mounted on right side of barrel.
  • Magazine is extended length.
  • Power cylinder is larger with 2 outer cylinders and 2 smaller central cylinders
  • Scope is a M38 1943 version
  • Scope rail is fitted onto rail blocks, one inside the rear sight and the other at the front end of the rail.
  • There are 3 swivel studs fitted, one on the rear stock and one each side of the front barrel housing.
  • Sling is 25mm webbing strap that is adjustable using a silver 25mm 3 fixed bar webbing buckle (optional).(not seen on remnant references)
  • Sling is fitted with Talon quick release 25mm swivel or replica (optional).(not seen on remnant references)
  • Red lights fitted on both sides of the rear housing, Hengstler fitted with a red light for the 3 forward tubes and 2 small red lights fitted into the rear barrel housing under the torch, the lights are permanent and are non flashing or pulsed (optional hero version only). (not seen on remnant references)
  • A flashlight mount is present on the right side of the blaster
  • A small flashlight shall may be mounted on the right side of the blaster centred over the T-Tracks.

 

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

  • Base is based on S&T Airsoft sterling with closed working parts (no spring)
  • Screws used are M4 x 25mm Allen screw/bolts and sunken Allen screws for power cylinders
  • Sling is fitted with Talon quick release 25mm swivel.
  • Scope must be correct M38 1943 version

OPTIONAL Level three certification (if applicable):

  • Power Cylinders shall be R1 style, ANH style is not allowed.
  • Blaster must be weathered
  • If flashlight is fitted must be working (this requirement consistent with other CRL's)

back.thumb.png.a230ff066fbed7a5bf184b93172b9c77.png

 

 

PAULDRON NOT SEEN ON REMNANT TROOPERS

Pauldron

 

Rogue One Pauldrons denote rank or mission specialization. The Rogue One Pauldron is specific to Rogue One and differs from the original trilogy in color and stitching. Original trilogy Pauldrons are not an authorized accessory for Rogue One armor.

 

  • An Orange, white, or black ornament made of leather plastic or leather-like material, worn over the right shoulder. The Orange is specific to Rogue One and a different shade from the original trilogy.
  • A red pauldron as seen in The Mandalorian Chapter 14, may be worn as part of the New Generation TK costume, but not as a Rogue One stormtrooper. 8/31/2022
  • The colored panel is divided into three sections by color matched stitching to conform to the wearers shoulder and has black piping around the outside edge.

     

  • The remainder of the Pauldron is black and divided by black stitching into 10 segments.

     

  • The neck closure is black and has two black snaps visible.

     

  • There is a black elastic strap that runs from back to front and is worn under the bicep to hold the Pauldron in place. The strap is conned to the Pauldron on top by two black snaps inlayed in black “D” shaped leather or leather-like ends.

     

  • The underside of the Pauldron is white regardless of top color and is divided with white stitching into 13 segments. The entire outside edge is finished with black piping and the underside of the neck closure is black.

     

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

 

OPTIONAL Level three certification (if applicable):

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, gmrhodes13 said:

PAULDRON NOT SEEN ON REMNANT TROOPERS

 Ok, we may have to rethink how requirements for the new generation armor are captured. I think I may have to start another thread just to keep these separate from the Remnant.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, BigJasoni said:

 Ok, we may have to rethink how requirements for the new generation armor are captured. I think I may have to start another thread just to keep these separate from the Remnant.

I thought it what was going to happen hence why I only concentrated on the Remnant there's too much info to compile in one thread in regards to multiple CRL's.

 

There are definitely some differences between Rogue One, Mandalorian, Mandalorian Remnant and Obi-Wan, whether these will constitute a new CRL for each is entirely up to the amount of differences and our DO and LMO's.

 

There are specifics to episodes as well and I know we want the general/standardized look but in some cases there are no other references and it's not a minor piece. Take pauldrons for instance, Rogue One, Mandalorian, Incinerator, Artillery and Sandtrooper/Jedha Crystal (although there is a mistake) all had 3 panel/stitched color sections BUT get to Mandalorian S2EP6 Chapter 14 and we have an example of a one piece color section which doesn't fit into any of this "new era" variants.

 

RO - Rogue One

Tk_rogue_one_pauldron.jpg

 

MI - Mandalorian Incinerator 

s-l500.jpg

 

MA - Mandalorian Artillery

ArtilleryTrooper-TMH.webp

 

OW - Obi Wan

Apart from the HWT's can't say I remember seeing any pauldrons but I've not delved into that as yet

 

RO/SOLO era - Rogue One Jedha / Crystal Sandtrooper

All 3 panel/stitched.

fbca7b6ef51acb54ac6c9bb6bba1c85f.jpg

q697Y2i.jpg

 

The Jedha trooper CRL has an error, the white pauldron is different to other Sandies not only is the ribbed section white but the closure should also be white not black as per reference below

R1_Jedha_Sandtrooper_Sergeant_Pauldron.p

7da800aa02c4f5fe4140eba26cffff9a.jpg

 

MB - Mimban

MimbanPauldron.png

 

MC - Mandalorian Commander

S2EP6 Chapter 14

And then we get to this trooper, no 3 panels/stitching which is different to all these era variants

2055218103_pauldronnolines.thumb.jpg.082e5a231bbc837ed7d59296882c7598.jpg

 

So this one wouldn't fit into the Rogue One CRL or a New Era Obi Wan as he doesn't have a holster, it may pop up in another series who knows.

 

That's just one example.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just to go back to the strapping, and I think it was the J hook cut outs, I am not inclined to start adding internal and usually hidden features and have them mandated in to our CRL's.

Strapping is a personal choice, so if someone wants to go to the effort of replicating those J's or any other type of hidden aspect, then that remains a decision entirely up to the individual.

What we do focus on is the external and trying to walk close to that line, some finer details that bring the outside visible parts closer to screen accuracy is what level 2 and 3 are definitely for.

Take for example the concealed zippers on TLJ forearms.  If a member wishes to replicate for their own self satisfaction, then that is wonderful, they most probably were not meant to be recognised on screen just as those J hooks are concealed under the shoulder bells and not forming an intricate highly visible part of the costume.

 

Outstanding work on this so far guys, we have some very strong cases for changes and I think an excellent CRL in the making. :th_AnimatedBravoSmiley:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree about not adding the J slot and strapping requirement and was searching for some references as I'd removed it from the suggested CRL text a few posts up, we have other costumes which are built the same way and we've not added those as requirements as they are internal strapping, like the Rogue One CRL, another example is Phasma's biceps with the J hooks and tab/velcro and they are not in that CRL, FOTK's had a tab/velcro strip there too and not a CRL requirement, a few examples.

large.costumes_of_rogue_one____stormtroo

 

NlcuxkZ.jpg

 

tab.png.ee06081c8f6b6b7ffafbf4b88ff3f6e8.png

 

I'm actually surprised that nobody building a phasma has enquired about an update for the CRL as you can clearly see the chest/yoke/back is hinged, shhhh perhaps I shouldn't mention it again :laugh1: Incidentally for anyone wondering no version of FOTK's had the hinge chest/yoke/back ;) 

 

Anyway back to Remnants :D 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The chroming process would have been a big issue with cracking and peeling in that area so it makes sense for this.

 

Here is a close up of an asset showing the J hook system on TFA seeing as you have already derailed the thread lol.

 

 

qP5Cw5Y.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, Sly11 said:

The chroming process would have been a big issue with cracking and peeling in that area so it makes sense for this.

 

Here is a close up of an asset showing the J hook system on TFA seeing as you have already derailed the thread lol.

 

 

qP5Cw5Y.jpg

Be a nice addition to the gallery section, I've not seen this detail previously although I presumed it would be the same as most other costumes have been in recent years. But I digress once again, back to the Remnant CRL

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Been looking over the remnant images again in regards to the belt, we have butted together and overlapped, and we have overlapping seen both ways, front over back and back over front, this is with the same belt/trooper too

 

over.thumb.png.6d50c1e76737357b13da2a196f214a0a.png

 

So should either be allowed?

 

Belt

  • Moderate to heavily weathered with a brownish hue
  • The Ammunition belt consists of a hard belt made of the same or similar material as the armor in two separate parts front and back, they can be either butted together or overlapped (with overlap).
  • The back belt overlaps the front belt on the sides
  • There are 6 ammunition boxes mounted to the belt.
  • There are 2 (one left and one right) drop boxes suspended by black webbing approximately 2" (50mm) wide. Drop boxes must be accurate in detail and proportion to official references.
  • The ammunition belt is accurate in detail and proportion to official references.
  • Bottom of belt may be completely straight or trimmed angular from the sides of the cod up to the drop boxes.

 

OPTIONAL Level two certification (if applicable):

  • The only detail visible on the front belt is the mounted ammunition boxes unlike the squares present on ANH belts.
  • The top edge of the front belt has protruding teeth that nest inside gaps between the ribs and detail panels of the abdominal armor.
  • The two center ammunition boxes are thinner than the other mounted ammunition boxes.
  • The second and fifth mounted ammunition boxes are slightly wider than the two center ammunition boxes.
  • The two outermost ammunition boxes are almost square.
  • The two drop boxes are rectangular and as wide as the mounted square boxes.

 

OPTIONAL Level three certification (if applicable):

  • The ammo boxes across the front are all made separately from the main belt and are secured to it
  • The two drop boxes hang no more than 1” 25mm below the front belt and the black strap is visible.
  • The second and fifth mounted ammunition boxes have trapezoid detail on the top of each ammunition box.
  • The front belt protrudes past all mounted ammunition boxes above and below by approximately 1/8”-1/4” 3-6mm.
  • All ammunition boxes have slightly bevelled edges on the face of each box.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

As this doesn't show any consistency I would agree that yes both ways should be allowable.

It's clear that the dressing department didn't take any notice or had a specific direction on this point.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

18 hours ago, Sly11 said:

As this doesn't show any consistency I would agree that yes both ways should be allowable.

It's clear that the dressing department didn't take any notice or had a specific direction on this point.

Or possibly on purpose?  To show the deterioration of discipline in addition to the deterioration of armor.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Dielotski said:

Or possibly on purpose?  To show the deterioration of discipline in addition to the deterioration of armor.

Could very well be

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 year later...

So, question for y'all... I've just got in my WTF ANH stunt armor and I'm starting my build... I see a lot of the reference material saying Rogue One armor for a Remnant build but since timeline wise...  RO happens before well, everything else in the OT, can I just weather my ANH armor into a Remnant look? For practical military logistical reasons, all of the armors would coexist in the empire just the same way it does in the current military.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, BaylorBear said:

So, question for y'all... I've just got in my WTF ANH stunt armor and I'm starting my build... I see a lot of the reference material saying Rogue One armor for a Remnant build but since timeline wise...  RO happens before well, everything else in the OT, can I just weather my ANH armor into a Remnant look? For practical military logistical reasons, all of the armors would coexist in the empire just the same way it does in the current military.

Unfortunately not, we have screen references of the armor used in RO and other recent series so we know what version armor it is. Timeline, Disney don't care about timeline and what version costume should have been used, we do however go off the screen references. 

 

TIME.png.c68de869c7043faef53ad1ad0ad98fc6.png

 

If you want a slightly dirty look you could do a HWT (heavy weapons trooper) or go full Sandy.

 

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...